The Smithy in Keld was a perfect place to spend a month on our trip home to England from Canada.. The cottage was perfect in everyway, great practical layout, very clean, and comfortably furnished. The water is hot and plentiful and the large shower on the main floor was nice for our mum, who celebrated her 90th birthday here. Our hosts Stuart and Doris were fantastic, warm, friendly and helpful. We will definately return again on our next trip back to England and recommend to anyone looking for a convenient cozy cottage for exploring the Yorkshire Dales and surrounding area.